Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label mooting

I miss coaching, I miss my Vis Moot team

An often forgotten thing about law is that it’s all words. Words in statutes, words in contracts, words in judgments, words in emails that make you wonder if some people have evolved beyond the need for punctuation. And yet, despite this, too many a law student (and, let’s be honest, quite a few lawyers) seem to believe they can master the trade without ever thinking too hard about language itself. They pore over legislation, memorise cases, and produce essays so structurally sound they could double as Brutalist architecture, but ask them to read a novel and they look at you like you’ve suggested taking up juggling as a form of professional development. Which is a shame, because literature teaches what no statute book ever will: how words work. It teaches rhythm, persuasion, subtext. It shows how meaning shifts depending on context, how ambiguity isn’t always a flaw but sometimes the very point. One can learn the law by reading legal texts, but no one can learn how to argue - really ar...

Returning to the mooting room

After a year-long hiatus, punctuated with a pleasant period of study leave and a harrowing few months on sick leave, I finally find myself, once again, in the familiar role of coaching my students for the Vis Moot. It is an endeavour that evokes ambivalence, akin to reuniting with an old friend who, while cherished, demands considerable time and energy. But let me be honest - how have I missed it! From an external perspective, the duties of a coach might seem limited to steering students through simulated legal proceedings, be it in an English courtroom or an American-style arbitration. Yet those who take part in a moot court, be they coaches or mooters, recognize its deeper essence. While the foundation undoubtedly lies in legal preparation and the students' professional growth, my emphasis - and the sentiment I strive to impart - transcends these bounds. When I speak to the new Vis Moot students, the first thing I try to stress upon is the fact that lawyers, and mooters, do not j...

Why I (Vis) Moot

With the 27th edition of the Vis Moot under way (and the 10th in which I am involved as coach and arbitrator), it has only taken five days for my annual interaction with a colleague asking me why I coach our Vis Moot team, and what is the point. Indeed, at first glance it may seem counter-productive: the University gives me 16 hours per term to coach the team, and I usually spend 20 hours in the first two weeks of preparation - which means that I basically take time off research or rest to coach the team; if (rectius, when) we do not win I am responsible, but the credit for any success goes to the students (and rightly so); I am not a PhD student and I do not need to go to Vienna with a team to enlarge my network - at this point in my career, I pretty much know who I need to know and I can be introduced to those I do not, and my yearly trip to Vienna is sufficiently justified by the desire to watch my team competing, arbitrating one or two good teams, and ingest as many wienerschnitzel...