Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label human rights

The poetics of suffering

 Suffering is a deeply subjective issue that questions the structure and theoretical objectivity of the legal system. The law seeks to classify and to draw defined boundaries around concepts as intangible as suffering, and it inevitably falters. It is here that literature can enter the stage, not as an antagonist to the law but as a companion, fluent in ambiguity where law demands clarity. If one considers how the law approaches the problem of suffering in the context of assisted dying, it appears that the courts mainly question how much suffering is too much, or what threshold must be crossed before the law permits a person to seek release. Judges are obviously constrained by precedent, language, and the fear of misstep, and the tools at their disposal, such as medical reports, philosophical arguments, and the cautious wisdom of case law, are far from straightforward. Courts must seek evidence, rationality, proof, but suffering is none of these things. I...

Papers that I'll likely never write: Of mice, men, and discrimination

 It's Christmas, I have ten spare minutes per day, and I'm re-reading a few classics. John Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men is the one I've just finished, roughly 20 years after my first rodeo, and it has sparked some reflections on disability discrimination (I was a fully abled biped the first time I read it, and my perspective was understandably different). It's a classic, so the following synopsis is more for my own benefit should I ever actually get to write this paper than for anyone else's. The book revolves around the story of two itinerant labourers, George Milton and Lennie Small, who harbour a shared dream of attaining independence through land ownership. Lennie is a man with a cognitive disability, and he depends on George for guidance and protection. However, this relationship is rendered tragic by society's lack of understanding and accommodation for Lennie’s condition. While much has been written about Steinbeck’s commentary on marginalisation, friends...

The symbolism of places of worship and their place in urban aesthetics: exploring the role of international law

Having had to spend the better part of last year on bed rest, I had considerable time to devote to researching and writing about the protection of places of worship under international law. While my article, soon to be published in Ephemerides Iuris Canonici , briefly touched upon a rather thought-provoking question on whether places of worship could also be considered as religious symbols, I was unable to delve into it due to constraints of space and coherence. However, peer-reviewers, colleagues, and even myself (if I can immodestly say so) recognized it as one of the most interesting aspects of the article. After submitting the final draft, the question continued to nag at me, prompting me to embark on a new side-project. While I have only drafted an extended abstract and shared it with a few colleagues, their insightful feedback has raised numerous pertinent questions, which could potentially take a decade to fully explore. Nevertheless, I am confident that this is a worthwhile res...

The rights of persons with disabilities in a post-conflict Ukraine and the failures of international law

This is the text of a talk delivered at "International law, conflict and disabilities: How do international conflicts affect disabled people?", webinar organized by Bringing [Dis]Ability to the Bar and Goldsmith Chambers on 29 March 2022. It briefly raises questions about how international law can protect persons with disabilities in post-conflict areas, with particular reference to Ukraine. First of all, I would like to thank Bringing my (Dis)Ability to the Bar and Goldsmith Chambers for organizing the event, and for inviting me to join the discussion. Even though Russia's invasion of Ukraine rightly monopolizes information spaces on traditional and new media, the space given to minority problems, which are exacerbated by the ongoing conflict, remains minimal, if not entirely absent, and events like this are fundamental for remembering which problems arise during a conflict, and which ones are ready to emerge as soon as the conflict ends. With my speech I intend to focu...

Minorities Denied

Strictly speaking, the European Convention on Human Rights (hereinafter referred to as “ECHR”) does not include a specific provision aimed at protecting religious minorities. The relevant provisions are indeed Article 9 (Freedom of thought, conscience and religion) and 14 (Prohibition of discrimination); and while neither provision explicitly deals with religious minorities, the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “ECtHR” or, simply, “the Court”) shows that the two provisions are in fact to be interpreted jointly and broadly. Article 9 not only provides for the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion, but also the ‘freedom to change [one’s] religion or belief and freedom, either alone or in community with others and in public or private, to manifest [their] religion or belief, in worship, teaching, practice and observance’; and such freedoms may be limited only ‘as […] prescribed by law and […] necessary in a democratic society in the interests of p...

Fair trial, the ECHR, and arbitration: a questionable approach

In a blog post of a few months ago , I questioned the international character of international commercial arbitration in light of the distinctive features of arbitration that emerged, at the national level, from our interviews. Indeed, the term "international commercial arbitration", in legal jargon, indicates a form of arbitration described in the most used teaching handbooks. Such form of arbitration, however, is characterized not only by the international character of the dispute, but also by a number of procedural aspects, principles and interpretative practices that are, in fact, specific of a minority of arbitration proceedings heard by a relatively small and exclusive group of practitioners, and mostly run in the main commercial arbitration hubs - especially Paris, London, Stockholm, Milan, Geneva, and New York. Together with this minority of high-profile cases, the realm of arbitration is widely populated by a large majority of international and domestic proceedings i...