Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label academia

How I accidentally started enjoying tort law

In a strange sort of accident, this academic year I’ve ended up teaching tort law. I didn’t set out to do it, really, and I certainly did not grow up thinking “yes, negligence and nuisance, that’s where I’ll plant my flag”. I picked it because I had to pick something, or it was going to be picked for me. One of those institutional inevitabilities, like fire doors that must be kept closed or the fact that the printer in the corridor is always out of toner (good thing that I don’t use that one anymore). I chose it because, faced with the list of core modules, it seemed like the one I would dislike the least. There’s a difference between liking and disliking the least; it’s the margin of survival. However, here I am, some weeks in, and I find myself, absurdly, enjoying it. I’m even starting to see the outlines of moral philosophy wearing the wig of practicality. People injure each other in the most inventive ways, and the law tries to make sense of that. Tort law, in its unassuming way, i...

Pages, fast breaks, and the illusion of progress

  It has been one of those rare weeks when things actually fall into place, or close enough to fool one into thinking they have. Between half-awake writing sessions at unholy hours and the usual avalanche of emails, I somehow managed to add a few more pages to my next monograph. A small victory, especially considering I sacrificed the mid-week Serie A match for it (Cagliari played atrociously, which in hindsight made my sacrifice feel almost saintly). Still, the real thrill came from taking my ideas out for a walk - almost literally, if could actually pull off a step. I presented Investment Arbitration’s Tightrope at Warwick to an engaged and curious audience, the sort of people who listen, think, and then ask the kind of questions that make one want to rewrite half their argument before dinner. Those encounters are rare these days – at least for an academic in my position (literal and otherwise), and when they happen they remind me why I started doing this whole academic thing in ...

Teaching law without religion is like explaining gravity without ever mentioning the earth

I am on annual leave, I am reading Javier Cercas' beautiful book on his trip to Mongolia with Pope Francis, and I am obviously thinking myself about how I teach law and religion (and, by the way, if the word “religion” makes you think only of incense smoke, Gregorian chants, or the big scary abstractions in comparative theology textbooks, you’re already missing the point): it’s not just one of those optional “modules” in the human-civilisation syllabus. It’s more like the deep slow-moving tectonic plate under the entire legal landscape, the one that explains why certain laws feel natural and others feel like the bureaucratic equivalent of being forced to wear someone else’s shoes. Some colleagues tend to pretend (or think, which is rather dangerous) that law is self-propelling—sui generis—as if its origins are purely in rational deliberation among formally equal actors. (They’re not.) In fact, legal systems have been marinated for centuries in the moral imaginaries of religious tra...

Lawyers at (empirical) work

There are few moments in academic life that so successfully simulate the futility of human endeavour as staring at a loading bar while 120,000 rows of data grind through a script like a constipated tortoise. It is a sort of epistemological purgatory: not quite Dante’s Inferno, but certainly the lesser-known ninth circle of Microsoft Excel. And here I am, a very occasional tourist in the land of empirical research trapped in this bleak waiting room of science, watching nothing happen in real time. I don’t do this often. Every two or three years, something compels me to wander outside the agreeable pastures of black-letter law into the pixelated trenches of data cleaning, coding, and praying that the file won’t crash. It is like jury duty or visiting relatives in hospital: necessary, slightly noble, best kept brief. This time, it is an ambitious little research project involving a mountain of institutional data. Somewhere in this digital mulch is the thing I’m looking for, like a signal,...

Notes on the academic year, part II

As part of trying to make sense of the year that just happened - teaching, writing, occasionally sleeping – I am starting here with some thoughts on my Law and Religion module. It was my first time teaching it, and like most firsts, it was equal parts thrilling, awkward, enlightening, and vaguely chaotic. But something happened when things clicked, and students cared; therefore, before it all blurs into next year’s to-do list, I wanted to write a little of it down. I called the first unit “Law, Religion and the Backstory” because it sounded like something a person might actually want to read (or click, these days) on. The idea was that each unit would be “Law, Religion and…” something - “Law, Religion and Rights,” “Law, Religion and the Courts,” “Law, Religion and the Infinite Bureaucratic Machine” - but it turns out the backstory is complicated, and possibly cursed. I was trying to be clever, or at least less boring than “History of Law and Religion,” which feels like a one-way ticket...

Notes on the academic year, part I

With today’s tutorial, I slam the door on the 2024–2025 academic year - a year that began, by most estimates, sometime after the Norman Conquest but before the invention of the dishwasher, and has only recently released us from its stubborn and faintly damp grasp. Term 1 stretched on like one of those Russian novels you feel virtuous owning but morally depleted trying to finish - page after page of existential trudgery. Term 2, by contrast, shot past like a shopping trolley (or my wheelchair) careening downhill: fast, erratic, and ending in a minor collision. Except for March. March, evidently, now comes in a new 14-week format, an extended director’s cut of confusion and deadlines. Since the memories are still vaguely warm, like the sad slice of toast forgotten under the tea towel, I am scribbling down some notes before the rot sets in, just enough to remind myself in October, when I’m muttering “how the hell did we get here again?” into my second coffee, that I have been through this...

I miss coaching, I miss my Vis Moot team

An often forgotten thing about law is that it’s all words. Words in statutes, words in contracts, words in judgments, words in emails that make you wonder if some people have evolved beyond the need for punctuation. And yet, despite this, too many a law student (and, let’s be honest, quite a few lawyers) seem to believe they can master the trade without ever thinking too hard about language itself. They pore over legislation, memorise cases, and produce essays so structurally sound they could double as Brutalist architecture, but ask them to read a novel and they look at you like you’ve suggested taking up juggling as a form of professional development. Which is a shame, because literature teaches what no statute book ever will: how words work. It teaches rhythm, persuasion, subtext. It shows how meaning shifts depending on context, how ambiguity isn’t always a flaw but sometimes the very point. One can learn the law by reading legal texts, but no one can learn how to argue - really ar...

Method, not meat

Is it my job to prepare students for legal practice? The question comes up often enough that I sometimes wish I had a little badge to flash when it’s asked - something modest, tasteful, nothing flashy, just a plain card reading "I am not a careers advisor". It would save time, and we would all be spared that awkward smile people give when they realize I’m not going to help their child learn how to write a 600-word brief. That's because teaching law is not about teaching the law. It’s about teaching students how to think about the law, which is like teaching someone how to play jazz by handing them sheet music for Bach. Yes, it’s incredibly hard work, but so is everything worthwhile. The trouble is that a lot of people misunderstand what education is for. They think I’m here to assemble barristers like IKEA wardrobes or to hammer out solicitors on some ancient academic forge. Sorry, but no. My job is to mess with their heads - not in the shifty-eyed, Kafkaesque sense (alth...

Is keeping up with academia just a fool’s errand?

As an academic lawyer, keeping up can sometimes feel impossible. Legal developments churn out at a pace that rivals London’s rush hour, and alongside them is the relentless stream of academic discourse online and in person. Papers, panels, journal articles, social media posts, webinars - every bit of it carrying an air of urgency, as if missing out might spell professional doom. At some point this past term I’ve started to wonder how much of it really matters. It’s not that I don’t care about the law or my work - quite the opposite: I define myself as an academic, to the point that losing use of 75% of my body wasn’t as much a trauma as it usually is for other winners of the spinal cord injury lottery, because I could keep doing what I love without too many adjustments. 1 But trying to stay ahead of every new decision, every article that might be tangentially related to my niche, and every panel discussion hosted in some far-flung time zone often feels less like intellectual enrichmen...

On writing (lectures)

 For fifteen years, I have resisted the siren call of the written lecture. Not out of laziness or disdain for preparation, but out of principle: from the moment I first stood in front of a classroom clutching a remote for a PowerPoint presentation, I always believed that the alchemy of a good lecture was not in the script, but in the delivery. I honed my craft during my PhD years, taking perhaps one too many public speaking workshop and eventually teaching some myself. It became clear to me that the essence of teaching was not in reading from a page, but in the living act of storytelling. Slides became my scaffolding, more detailed when the subject matter was unfamiliar, sparser and more evocative when it was well within my wheelhouse. The classroom became a sort of a stage, and at times I acted as equal parts scholar and raconteur (whether I was any good at the latter should be a question for my former students). This approach has served me well: over the years, I have relished th...

Taking time seriously

A new academic year is starting tomorrow and for some unclear reason I am feeling thrilled. Obviously, what is getting my blood pumping is not the prospect of teaching per se – that can be amazing, obviously, but after a few years it becomes too familiar a feeling to be a source of excitement – but rather the necessary structure and discipline it demands. I figured out, over the years, that summer may not be the most productive time of the year for me, writing-wise. I certainly have much more time in my hands than during teaching terms, but I also realised that open-ended mornings and afternoons make for fantastic reading slots – not so much for writing. Teaching brings with itself a schedule, non-negotiable commitments, and a sense of urgency: if I want to write until my class at 3 pm, I must get to it as soon as possible, which means that I have to deal with emails, administration and other less-than-interesting tasks quickly so that I have that coveted couple of hours to write. The ...

On rules, principles, and teaching international law

As an educator, I am always pondering my teaching methods and questioning whether they are adequate for my students' growth. I have recently revisited Karl Llewellyn's " The Bramble Bush ", a book that had a profound impact on my intellectual and academic development. In the very first pages, Llewellyn demystifies the legend that the study of law is (or could be) limited to learning the rules. His words made me consider my own teaching, and how much of it is reliant on the shortcut of simply paraphrasing the rules. While teaching jurisprudence, I can easily avoid using specific provisions, except for rudimentary examples when necessary, and prioritize instead instilling the underlying principles in my students. Similarly, when it comes to teaching investment law, I have found that focusing on specific treaty rules may prove futile. Although the rules may be virtually the same across different treaties, the diversity in their interpretation by tribunals renders them un...

Why I (Vis) Moot

With the 27th edition of the Vis Moot under way (and the 10th in which I am involved as coach and arbitrator), it has only taken five days for my annual interaction with a colleague asking me why I coach our Vis Moot team, and what is the point. Indeed, at first glance it may seem counter-productive: the University gives me 16 hours per term to coach the team, and I usually spend 20 hours in the first two weeks of preparation - which means that I basically take time off research or rest to coach the team; if (rectius, when) we do not win I am responsible, but the credit for any success goes to the students (and rightly so); I am not a PhD student and I do not need to go to Vienna with a team to enlarge my network - at this point in my career, I pretty much know who I need to know and I can be introduced to those I do not, and my yearly trip to Vienna is sufficiently justified by the desire to watch my team competing, arbitrating one or two good teams, and ingest as many wienerschnitzel...

Applying to a PhD Programme (IMHO)

(Last Updated on 29 September 2019) Just like anyone employed in a research position at a University, I receive my fair share of weekly questions and unsolicited projects from prospective PhD applicants. I reply to each email out of courtesy, as it is very rare for one of these emails to pick my interest. It is not a snobbish approach - in fact, anecdotal evidence (I have just asked 10 of my colleagues, randomly chosen) suggests that my average is rather high. The reason for this is, predictably, that most of these requests can be placed on a spectrum, at one extreme of which is the dramatically naïve proposal, which is months of work away from being interesting, and at the other is the completely irrelevant one (and I am not talking about something on a field of international law I do not even teach - I am referring to proposals in criminal law, equity and trusts, land law or any other subject I have not seen since I was an undergraduate student, if ever). There are colleagues who lau...